For Excellus Medicare Advantage members

MAKE YOUR VOICE HEARD

Help protect access to independent medical care. Share your concerns with Excellus and elected officials.

Click either button above to open a pre-addressed email draft with the subject and message already filled in. Add your information, then send. If no email app opens, the review, edit or copy form below will open automatically so you can copy the details into a new email.

All Community Members-Email Elected Officials · review, edit, copy

This email goes to Excellus and the elected officials listed below. Excellus and Empire Dermatology are copied. You can adjust recipients and wording in your email app before sending.

Replace bracketed placeholders and adjust the message to reflect your circumstances. For a message to several elected officials, you may use “Dear Elected Representatives.” Please do not include medical details or your insurance member ID.

If your mail app does not open or any text is missing, copy the recipients, CC address, subject, and full message into a new email.

Excellus Medicare Advantage Members – Email Excellus & Elected Officials · review, edit or copy

This email goes to Excellus and the elected officials listed below. Excellus and Empire Dermatology are copied. You can adjust recipients and wording in your email app before sending.

Replace bracketed placeholders and adjust the message to reflect your circumstances. For a message to several elected officials, you may use “Dear Elected Representatives.” Please do not include medical details or your insurance member ID.

If your mail app does not open or any text is missing, copy the recipients, CC address, subject, and full message into a new email.

Why Excellus’s New Reimbursement Policy Matters to Patients

To the Editor:

Imagine visiting your doctor and learning that you also need a minor procedure. If both can safely and appropriately be addressed that day, most patients would prefer one visit instead of returning another day.

A new Excellus BlueCross BlueShield reimbursement policy has us concerned about whether this kind of efficient, patient-centered care could become more difficult for independent practices to provide.

Modifier 25 applies when a patient receives a medically necessary office visit and a separate, medically necessary procedure on the same day. This new policy reduces reimbursement for the lower-cost service when both are provided together.

Excellus says the policy is not intended to encourage separate visits. Our concern is the unintended consequence: reducing reimbursement for providing these services together could discourage same-day care that saves patients another appointment, time away from work or family, and treatment delays.

We aren’t alone in raising concerns. The American Medical Association (AMA), NYS Society of Dermatology and Dermatologic Surgery, Medical Society of the State of New York and American Academy of Dermatology have met with Excellus.

According to the AMA, private-practice physicians declined from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024.1 Research has also found that when physician practices are acquired by hospitals or health systems, healthcare prices and spending can increase without consistent quality improvements.

No single policy will determine the future of independent medicine. But payment pressures, rising costs and administrative burdens add up.

We urge Excellus to work with physicians toward a solution that protects efficient patient care and preserves access to independent medicine in Central New York.

Signed,

Central New York Physicians
Name Specialty / role Practice
Brian Raphael MD Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Jeffrey Cizenski MD Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Michael Kuhn MD Internal medicine FamilyCare medical group
Kirby Black, MD Emergency Medicine —
Robert Hill MD Ophthalmology/oculofacial plastics Eye Plastic & Reconstructive Surgeons of CNY
George Salloum MD Ophthalmology/oculofacial plastics Eye Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons of CNY
Kavitha Prezzano, MD Radiation Oncology Hematology Oncology Associates of CNY
Nathanial Miletta MD Dermatology Samaritan Dermatology & Mohs Surgery
Joseph Housel, MD, MBA Dermatology Housel Dermatology, PC
Brad Yentzer, MD Dermatology Finger Lakes Dermatology PLLC
James Prezzano MD Dermatology Fayetteville Dermatology – Syracuse
Avni Patel Black MD Family Medicine Family care medical group
Anjali Sura MD Pediatric Rheumatology —
Gregory Baum, MD Plastic Surgery CNY Cosmetic & Reconstructive Surgery
Erinn White MD Otolaryngology Syracuse ENT Surgeons
Jeffrey LaDuca MD Dermatology Reflections Dermatology
Hannah Singer, MD, FAAD Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Kathryn Somers MD Dermatology Flower City Dermatology
Diana Stephens, MD Dermatology Geneva General Dermatology
Emily Lambert MD Dermatology Geneva General Dermatology
Sphoorthi Jinna, MD Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Anthony Chiaravalloti, MD Dermatology Reflections Dermatology
Eric Fung, MD Otolaryngology Syracuse ENT Surgeons
Patrick Chiles MD Otolaryngology Syracuse ENT surgeons
Amanda Carpenter, MD Dermatology Geneva General Dermatology
Amy Reynders, MD Otolaryngology Syracuse ENT Surgeons
Bryant Carruth, MD Ophthalmology Eye Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons of CNY
Breana Diana Gallagher PA-C Dermatology Housel Dermatology
Elizabeth Johnson PA-C Dermatology Housel Dermatology
Maria Naylor PA-C Dermatology Housel Dermatology
Anthony Deboni MD Plastic Surgery CNY Cosmetic & Reconstructive Surgery
Maggie N. Garland PA-C Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Margaret Drescher PA-c Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Alisa Murphy PA-c Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Heidi DiMeis FNP Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Katie Pavlisko PA-C Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Jennifer Johansson, PA-C Dermatology Housel Dermatology, PC
Beth Lertzman MD Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Rachel Dorrer PA-C Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Colleen Vaccaro, PA-C Dermatology Empie Dermatology
Meghan Doran, FNP-C, DCNP Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Jenna Pawloski FNP-C Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Anne St Pierre FNP-BC,DCNP Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Victoria Pirro PA-C Dermatology Empire Dermatology
Jesse Ryan MD Otolaryngology University Otolaryngology
Ramsay Farah MD FAAD Dermatology Farah Dermatology and Cosmetics
Joyce Farah MD Dermatology Farah Dermatology and cosmetics
Michal Raphael PA-C Hematology and Oncology Hematology Oncology Associates of CNY
Thomas Bersani MD Ophthalmology Eye Plastic and Reconstructive Surgeons of CNY

Source

1. American Medical Association. Physician Practice Characteristics in 2024: Private Practices Account for Less Than Half of Physicians in Most Specialties. AMA Physician Practice Benchmark Survey, 2024. The share of physicians in private practice declined from 60.1% in 2012 to 42.2% in 2024.

Information for our patients

Latest updates

Excellus payment policy and patient access

Updated October 13, 2026

Planning for continued access to care

Unless we reach a resolution with Excellus, Empire Dermatology is likely to become out of network with Excellus in 2027. While this is not yet final, we want patients to be aware now because we understand how important it is to plan for continued access to care.

Read the frequently asked questions ↓

What patients should know

Frequently asked
questions

Excellus payment policy and patient access

Will Empire Dermatology be out of network with Excellus in 2027?

Unless we reach a resolution with Excellus, Empire Dermatology is likely to become out of network with Excellus in 2027. While this is not yet final, we want patients to be aware now because we understand how important it is to plan for continued access to care.

What is the new payment policy?

Excellus BlueCross BlueShield has changed how it pays physicians when a patient receives a medically necessary office evaluation and a separate, medically necessary minor procedure on the same day. Under the policy, the higher-paid service is reimbursed at the full allowed amount, while payment for the lower-paid service is reduced by 25%.

Does the policy prevent me from receiving an evaluation and a procedure on the same day?

No. The policy permits same-day care but reduces payment for the lower-paid service. Empire supports same-day care when clinically appropriate. Our concern is whether these payment terms allow us to sustainably remain in the Excellus network.

When appropriate, receiving both services during one appointment can mean less travel, less time away from work or family, and fewer delays in treatment.

Will I need an additional appointment because of this policy?

The policy does not require separate appointments. Whether another visit is needed should depend on your medical needs and your clinician’s judgment.

Is my health insurance plan changing?

The reimbursement policy itself does not change your plan’s covered benefits. However, continued in-network access to Empire depends on our network participation. If we leave the Excellus network, your coverage and costs for care here could change depending on your plan.

Why is Empire Dermatology concerned?

Excellus’s payment reduction creates significant financial challenges while staffing, supply, and other operating costs continue to rise. We do not believe this policy is financially sustainable for our practice. Our concern is our ability to remain in network and continue caring for Excellus patients.

Our greatest concern is what this could mean for patients. Losing in-network access to Empire could mean higher out-of-pocket costs, difficulty continuing with a physician you know and trust, or traveling farther to find another in-network provider.

Does receiving two services mean the same work is billed twice?

A separately billed office evaluation must involve significant, separately identifiable work beyond the care normally included in the procedure. Some resources may be shared during one appointment, but an appropriately billed separate evaluation represents additional clinical work. Empire’s concern is whether the payment reduction appropriately reflects that work and supports continued access to care.

Excellus says the policy avoids duplicate payments. Why do Empire, other local physicians, and politicians disagree?

We agree that insurers should not pay twice for the same work. But a properly billed office evaluation and a separate procedure represent distinct, medically necessary services, not duplicate care. Existing Medicare payment valuation methods already account for overlapping work and expenses in services commonly provided together. We are concerned that Excellus’s additional 25% reduction to the lower-paid service risks reducing payment again for efficiencies already reflected in those valuations, making convenient same-day care harder to sustain.

Could financial pressure on independent practices increase healthcare costs?

Yes. Financial pressure can push independent practices to join larger hospital systems, potentially reducing patient choice and increasing prices. A 2018 study found that prices for physician services increased by an average of 14.1% after hospital acquisition. That does not mean every acquisition produces the same increase, but it reinforces why preserving independent practices matters to patients, employers, and the affordability of care.

Will my bill increase by 25%?

The reduction applies to Excellus’s payment for the lower-paid service. It does not automatically mean a 25% increase in your bill. Your costs depend on your plan and the services provided. If Empire becomes out of network, your coverage and costs for care here could change.

What would being out of network mean for me?

If Empire becomes out of network, your costs and coverage for care here could change. Depending on your plan, you may have out-of-network benefits, face higher out-of-pocket costs, or have no coverage for routine out-of-network care.

You can contact Excellus using the number on your insurance card to ask about your out-of-network benefits. We will provide more specific guidance if a network change is confirmed.

What is Empire doing to prevent this?

We are seeking a sustainable resolution with Excellus that allows us to continue caring for patients in network. Unless a resolution is reached, we are likely to become out of network in 2027.

What can I do now?

If keeping in-network access to Empire matters to you, please contact Excellus Member Services using the number on your insurance card. Explain that you are concerned about potentially losing access to your physician in 2027 and ask Excellus to work toward a resolution that keeps Empire in network.

You can also share your concerns with your elected representatives. Sharing your concerns is optional and does not affect your care. We are informing patients now so they have time to understand the risk and prepare for a potential network change.